60 people bested this!2 people are curious. |
Do you think this is the best? 
|
Get Great Stuff at 
(and other places we like)
Members that think Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is the best!
Comments
So far this is the best book for me. And I’m sure I’ll like it better than the 7th/last book :)
Just read this for the first time, and after the awesomeness of the first two, I don't really like this one.
It starts off well, and there's no denying it's success and charm for the majority of the book, but it completely falls apart in the closing chapters, with revelations of complete illogicalaties. It all goes a bit nonsensical, and the characters, no matter how good they may be, simply can't convince otherwise.
You can't judge fantasy on logistics or whether or not it comes off as nonsensical. Thats why its called fantasy.
Granted, but judging the closing chapters on their literal efficiency and pacing it's a mess.
It's fantasy- of course it's allowed to be entirely illogical, but the structure of those chapters and their content in relation to the ones before it just don't add up at all. The ending comes from nowhere at all with no exposition of the plot details throughout the book. It not only turns the story on it's head, it renders it oh-so pointless and without meaning.
i love harry potter series… Daniel Racliffle my favourite..